“The Free State of Jones” on Film: A Q&A with Victoria Bynum, Megan Kate Nelson, Society of Civil War Historians homepage website, March 2, 2016.
This May, STX Entertainment will release the film Free State of Jones,
which tells the story of the Knight Company and the Jones County
rebellion, a Civil War history first told by Victoria Bynum in her 2001 book The Free State of Jones.
A few weeks ago, Bynum and I discussed her experiences working as a
consultant on the film, and seeing her book come alive on the screen.
MKN: Did you know at the time you were writing “The Free State of
Jones” that it had cinematic potential? And what is it about this story
that makes it compelling for filmmakers?
VB: As I researched and wrote The Free State of Jones, I
grew increasingly aware of its historical importance as an insurrection
that combined elements of class, race, gender, and kinship that, for
this story, had long been underestimated, misunderstood, distorted, or
Although I did not write the book with a movie in mind, the story’s
vivid real-life characters, its oral and written first-hand accounts of
fierce confrontations between Confederates and deserters, the
interracial romance between the band’s leader, Newt Knight, and his
slave accomplice, Rachel Knight, and the Unionist core of the band
itself, convinced me of the story’s cinematic potential.
On the standard author’s questionnaire that I completed for the
University of North Ca
rolina Press, I advised the press to consider
presenting the book “to television and film companies as a potential
docudrama or miniseries.” At that point, however, I did not anticipate
Hollywood’s interest in the story.
MKN: As the process of transforming the book into the film got
underway, what was it like to experience the subjects and arguments in
your book morphing into a visual format?
VB: When I visited the movie set in Louisiana, I watched actor
Matthew McConaughey recreate Newt Knight’s pivotal experiences at the
battle of Corinth. I was pleased at the manner in which Gary Ross,
director and author of the movie’s screenplay, targeted the beginning
stage of Newt’s evolution into a class-conscious opponent of the
Confederacy, and I was impressed by McConaughey’s ability to immerse
himself in the role, both physically and psychologically.
I’ve since viewed the movie’s trailer, and was likewise impressed
with the way in which class issues, front-line participation by women,
and collaboration between deserters and slaves in this home front
insurrection came to life on the screen.
I’ve not yet seen the entire movie, so can’t comment on the completed product. Based on what I have seen, I’m hopeful that the movie captures the essential elements of defiance and struggle that drew me to the story.
MKN: Was there anything that worried you, or surprised you about that process?
VB: Like most historians, I worried about the movie’s factual
accuracy. Over time, my thinking has evolved on the creative differences
between an academic work of history and a historically-based movie.
Both rely on imagination, but in very different ways. Historians don’t
merely assemble facts, apropos the cliché, “let the facts speak for
themselves.” We must use imagination as well as intellect to assign the
elusive truth of meaning to our work, or we risk producing little more than a footnoted list of facts.
In contrast to historians, Hollywood moviemakers use imagination to
recreate a historic event that can be viewed within the space of 2-3
hours. The larger truth of an event is typically delivered without
perfect adherence to facts—but rather with invented dialogue, composite
characters and compressed events—to tell a true story that informs,
inspires and entertains. My expectation is that the movie and my book
will mutually reinforce the larger truth of about the Free State of
MKN: You published “The Free State of Jones” in 2001; why do think
that the time is finally right — in 2014-5 — to make it into a film?
VB: Actually, I first learned in 2005 that plans for a movie based on
the history of the Free State of Jones were underway. As is often the
case in Hollywood, the journey to production was a slow one.
That said, Hollywood’s current interest in portraying Civil War
dissenters is well-timed to highlight issues being debated with
particular force in this national election year. Federal vs. state
power, stark economic inequality, and fierce confrontations over racial,
class, and gender rights all divide Americans.
Amid these battles, the popularity of the Lost Cause defense of the
Confederate flag as a symbol of “white heritage” has spiked,
particularly on social media. The Free State of Jones reminds
us that there was neither a Solid (white) South during the Civil War
era, nor a monolithic white heritage embodied by the Confederate flag.
MKN: How do you hope the film will shape Americans’ understanding of Civil War history?
VB: Most Americans know little to nothing about landowning,
nonslaveholding white Southerners of the antebellum and Civil War South,
which in turn prevents them from fully understanding the average
Southerner’s experience of the Civil War. In bringing the story of the
Free State of Jones to the masses, not only is the image of a white
Solid South negated, so also is the agency of Southern dissenters during
the era of the Civil War and Reconstruction asserted. This represents
an important shift in the general manner in which Hollywood has
presented the Civil War.
MKN: What advice do you have for historians writing with an eye
toward film adaptation, or working as consultants on films about
VB: Since I did not write The Free State of Jones with such
an eye, my remarks are speculative. I’ve heard it said that authors who
intend to pitch their work to film companies should retain the
intellectual rights to their manuscripts (which, in academia, are
generally held by the press). I suppose one would consider hiring a
literary agent, as well.
In the aftermath of having the rights to my book purchased by a
Hollywood studio, however, I have benefited from the University of
North Carolina Press’s commitment to publishing a new edition of the
book and marketing it internationally.
I have no specific advice in regard to finding work as a film
consultant. I was asked to be a consultant for The Free State of Jones
movie on the basis of my book of the same name. Several other historians
were hired as consultants based on their works on related historical
Victoria Bynum is Distinguished Professor Emeritus of History at
Texas State University, San Marcos. A graduate of the University of
California, San Diego, an award-winning author and NEH Fellow, she has
produced cutting-edge scholarship on gender, race, and class relations
in the Civil War Era South for more than thirty years. Her blog, Renegade South, features unruly women, mixed-race families, anti-Confederate guerrillas, and political dissenters.
Full Text Source: Society of Civil War Historians